I've got 4000km on my 2004 Forester 2.5XS (5spd manual). Moderate acceleration from 2600rpm through about 3700rpm is lumpy. Lumpy is probably the best way to describe it. Whatever it is, it is definately not smooth acceleration. Operating and shifting at 4000+rpm, the engine sounds strained, like it's time to shift. Occasionaly I have noticed rough idle when sitting at a stop light. Any ideas?
My 90 Legacy with 2.2 (5spd manual) certainly doesn't have this lumpy acceleration and the shift rpms I use in it are 2500 - 3300rpm, depending on acceleration requirements. The 2.2, though 15years and 180,000km older feels like it produces better and smoother power, even in the heavier car. mmm?