Okay, you guys gave me some good direction on my problem and I've done a lot of reading and looking at diagrams. I think that port is intended to be open.
I started suspecting the EGR possibly so I felt through the back of it and it is definitely stuck open. The diaphram never moves hot or cold, throttle open or not.
Also, I noticed a small amount of gas on the outside of the fuel pump. So I drained some oil and there is a small amount of gas in it. I'm theorizing that when the car wasn't running, the fuel filter gummed up and that put a strain on the fuel pump, causing it to start to fail.
I'm going to replace the EGR and the pump and I'll report back with my results, if anyone is interested.
Thanks for all the help, everyone!