Presidents do not have the write to rewrite the law
Mar 03, 2008 48 Replies
J
Jeff
I am not sure of that. There are over 1,000,000,000 people all fighting for resources in India. Some of the rivers are open sewers. There is war in Iraq and Afghanistan, and some African countries. When people are fighting for their lives, the environment as an issue goes down the tubes.
Jeff
Didn't find your answer? Ask the community — no account required.
J
JoeSpareBedroom
I was referring more to governmental resistance and secrecy as the main problems. But, you're correct about those other factors.
W
witfal
Bingo. Give that man a cee-gar.
M
Mike hunt
Does the court expect us to believe it is better to let people kill American than for Americans to possibly kill a whale?
J
Jeff
The court's opinion on the value of American lives vs. Whale lives is not relevant. The relevant question is, "Do the President and Navy have to follow US law?"
I suggest that you read the court's opinion, which you can find at the website of the 9th circuit's website. In addition, you can find the opinion of the district court. Google can help you find them. In addition, I have provided a link to the circuit court's opinion previously in this thread.
Jeff
J
JoeSpareBedroom
Hunt has read nothing about the issue at all. He's too busy.
J
JoeSpareBedroom
True, but this particular president doesn't seem capable of understanding of how little is being asked of the Navy.
"Under the court decision, the Navy must maintain a 12 nautical mile no-sonar buffer zone along the California coast, shut down sonar when marine mammals are spotted within 2,200 yards (meters) and avoid whale habitats among other measures."
The ruling relates to training exercises. I'm sure nobody expects the Navy to obey the ruling if they feel an enemy is within that 12 mile limit, although I'm sure someone in this newsgroup will argue this point.
M
Mark A
I doubt seriously that it was the president who decided to have the military do this. It was most likely career military officers, some (or many) of whom are Democrats.
J
JoeSpareBedroom
If you're not part of the solution.....
You know the rest of that sentence.
Join the Discussion
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Didn't find your answer?
Ask the community — no account required
Report Content
You are reporting this content to the moderators. They will look at it
ASAP.