Original oil filter way too tight! (04 Golf)

Take it to a VW dealer. They should be able to get it off.

NO, it's not a "defect" if you have the correct tool to remove the filter. Check with the techs at your dealer and have them show you what they use to get the filter off... and BTW you need to remove it from under the car.

I had a really hard time getting the filter off of my Passat 1.8T. I ended up using a strap wrench. That worked like a champ. Kurt

Thanks. Would you happen to know what kind of tool the VW techs do use to remove the filter?

Understood -- and attempted.

Someone else suggested a strap wrench, BTW; that was the first thing I tried, but in this case it was totally ineffective.

Rich Wales snipped-for-privacy@richw.org

Drive a screwdriver through the filter, turn.

Clean up the oil spill with kitty litter.

Next?

I've had it happen too... PITA, put the old oil back in and took it to the dealers.

I finally took it to a mechanic. He told me afterwards that he had needed to use a two-foot-long breaker bar in order to produce enough torque to remove the original oil filter.

Rich Wales snipped-for-privacy@richw.org

One of those big channel lock type oil filter wrenches. :)

Scary German thinking...

:)

"Peter Parker" replied:

The independent mechanic who finally removed the filter used a two-foot-long breaker bar, together with some sort of three- fingered "claw" type of tool to grip the sides of the filter.

When I described what had been needed to a dealer service manager (who had earlier refused to loosen the filter for free as a warranty repair), he agreed that this was much more force than should have been necessary.

A conventional filter wrench (e.g., a cheap strap wrench) would not have been suitable, because there is not enough clearance around the sides of the filter (various A/C and radiator hoses). I tried using a strap wrench with a swivel handle, but I wasn't able to produce enough torque and didn't have a breaker bar.

Rich Wales snipped-for-privacy@richw.org

Just saving money, 3 grams of oil on each filter seal does add up over 100 or so years!

I've had to use this method too, although as last resort. I'm always afraid of shredding the whole thing and leaving just the stump that still won't come off.

It may help to try loosening it up when it's at its coldest outside too and everthing is more contracted.