I speak from experience, albeit high mileage, but that is perhaps even more important.
I've owned both an Accord and a 90 Quattro. Both cars were 1988 models and both had about 120K on them. The Accord was butt ugly in my artistic opinion but it faithfully moved me down the road for 4 years until it decided to develop an unpredictable massive electrical failure that would pop up now and then unexpectedly. While it was for the most part dependable during those 4 years, it lacked any excitement whatsoever except for the pronounced oversteer it exhibited if I mashed it in first or second around a sharp turn. The seats were broken down so you could feel the frame against your thorasic spine. This proved problematic when I was rearended by a Voyager at low speed.
I ended up dumping the car for $50.00 when I found my 1988 90Quattro. I was immediately reminded of what I like about German cars. The suspension was still tight after all those miles, the seats still provided support where needed, the body was more solid providing a quieter ride and it is overall just a better made car. I has a MUCH better sound system MUCH better back seat and MUCH better handling and braking characteristics. My biggest complaint is that the normally aspirated 5 cyl engine is a bit underpowered for the car's weight.
Anyone who thinks that the Quattro system is dead weight except in snow or on wet pavement either hasn't driven the car, or doesn't know how to drive except in a straight line. I realize that for kids speed off the line is important. I was there once. But when I learned how to drive on winding roads I then realized my priorities were out of whack. Today, for me, handling characteristics at high speed are much more important.
Finally, in '02 when we were looking at new cars, my wife an I looked at the A4 and A6 and accepted the fact that they were out of our price range. We also testdrove a Passat 4Motion. We then made the obligatory visit to the Honda dealer and test drove their top of the line Accord. Boy, what a disappointment after driving the Audi and VW! Since the
4Motion was only about $3K more than the Accord, it it was an easy decision.1987 Mercedes 300 SDL
1988 Audi 90 Quattro 2002 Passat 4Motion