Does it really put out more power than the 4.3L V-6 in my S-10?
Well, I only have a little over 3000 miles on the I-5 so far. It does seem to perform well, but I'm not sure the transmission shifts at the best points or firmly enough to take advantage of it. It pulls my little boat just fine. I haven't put my big boat behind it yet. Mostly becasue the truck is just to darn close to the ground. I may have to give it a couple inches of lift.
Does it pull the little boat faster and/or in higher gears than the S-10? Well, yes, but that isn't a fair comparison. I have an extra tall Gemtop work cap on the S-10 with several fiberglass ladders stacked ontop, and several hundred pounds of tools and supplies inside the cap. Basically an extra 1000 to 1300 pounds in the bed everyday.
In all honesty I did add three leaf springs and run a Super Chips programmer on the 4.3L S-10 so I suppose to run a fair comparison I need to run a similar program on the I-5, and then get loaded fully down as a work truck.
It does sound funny when idling.