Re: Bogus Worst 50 Car List [was: Re: Is General Motors Worth Saving?]

I won't comment on the whole article, but one of the links cited in the

>article, "The 50 Worst Cars of All Time" was typical of the sort of crap >you get from non-technical people (see ". >
formatting link
>. > > First complaint - can anyone actually know this? What is you frame of > reference? > > Second complain - some of the "worst cars" were not even real cars or > production vehicles. > > Comments on some specific selections: > > 1909 Model T - come on, no way this make any list of worst cars if you > keep it in context. Was a 1929 Model a fairly poor car compared to other > cars in 1929 - probably. But a 1909 compared to other 1909 cars in its > price range? No way. > > 1933 Fuller Dymaxion - this wasn't even a production vehicle. > > 1934 Chrysler/Desoto Airflow - Maybe unpopular, but worst? No way. > > 1956 Renault Dauphine - horrible in America, loved in France. I'll admit I > hated them, but hardly one of the worst 50 WORST OF ALL TIME. > > 1957 Waterman Aerobile - not a real production vehicle. > > 1958 Ford Edsel - Like the Airflow, unpopular, unsuccessful, but not one > of the worst 50. > > 1958 Lotus Elite - ??????? A great car for it's intended use. > > 1958 MGA Twin Cam - If this is on the list, you might as well list every > other Post WWII British Sports Car, and then they would fill the whole > list. > > 1961 Corvair - Geez. This is ridiculous. Compared to anything from Japan > in 1961 and most things from Europe, a 1961 Corvair was a great car. It > shows up on these lists because a wacko liberal wrote a misleading book > trashing the Corvair. > > 1970 AMC Gremlin - Odd looking, yes, one of the worst 50, no way. > > 1971 Ford Pinto - on the list based solely on lies. The Pinto was not > particularly fire prone, and the memo alleged to exist in the article > never existed. A lazy journalist repeating the lies of another lazy > journalist repeating the lies of a liar.... > > 1976 Chevy Chevette - although it was actually more likely to catch fire > than a Pinto, it wasn't a bad car at all. > > 1980 Ferrari Mondial 8 - if this is one of the worst, I want to be bad.... > > 1995 Ford Explorer - this is on the list because the guy hates SUVs, not > because it is inherently a bad vehicle. So it seems at least some of the > vehicles are on the list because they are not politically incorrect. > > 2000 Ford Excursion - same sort of BS as with the Explorer. He basically > says there was nothing wrong with the vehicle, except the wrong people > bought them. > > 2002 BMW 7-series - another car on the worst list that makes me want to go > over to the dark side. > > After looking through this worst list, I am convinced it is mostly a list > of the most "Politically Incorrect Cars" with a few "Poor Marketing > Decision Cars" and a few truly bad cars thrown in by a lazy writer trying > to meet a deadline. Any "worst car" list that doesn't include the Copper > Cooled Chevrolet cannot be trusted. How many cars are so bad that the > company buys them all back and sinks them in lake Michigan (well all but > 2). > > Ed
Reply to
Woody
Loading thread data ...

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.