Oil change 5k

Mar 28, 2008 9 Replies

mk4 golf 1.6



Was advised by my local specialist I should change the oil every 5k even though the manual says 10k. I pointed this out to his and he said thats correct but a good oil change means the world for the engine and can help prolong its life.



He a good guy and never done the dirsty on me so to speak and has offered the oil change for free, + oil filter.



Is it nescessary to change the oil every 5k or is this excessive ?



Will it make a difference in the engine life ?



I put good oil in it semi synthetic recommeneded stuff sytha stuff from GSF car parts. 10/40



Just curious on the panels views.


It won't make a blind bit of difference, the bodywork will die before the engine wears out due to lack of lubrication.

I keep the oil topped up, doesn't really drink a lot to be honest so just every no and then top it up so everything works as it should.

I'm getting alot of conflicting advice about oil changes though, some say go for 5k some say 10k.

I'll stick with the manual and stick with 10k.

Highly unlikely on a Mk 4 Golf, to be fair.

Unless you do very short trips, 10k changes may be better for your engine than 5k changes.

Studies relating wear to oil change frequency seem to agree that wear is greatest for some time just _after_ an oil change.

"Testing with partially stressed oil, which contained some wear debris, produced less wear than testing with clean oil. This finding was unexpected and initially confusing (further inquiry suggested that the result was not so surprising, as many oil chemistries require time and temperature to enhance their effectiveness)."

formatting link
John

SteveH ( snipped-for-privacy@italiancar.co.uk (SteveH)) gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

The car will certainly die before the engine, but it won't be rot. It'll be the usual miscellany of small niggles that just make it not worth fixing.

If I were doing low mileage, I'd probably do a 5k / 6 month oil change. If I were racking up the miles at a fair rate, I'd do it every 10k...

Very interesting read.

Thanks for the link John.

Interesting - so new oil needs to be 'run in' for a period...

Quite a while it seems. The site where I first saw this claim has disappeared, but thankfully not before it got archived:

formatting link
" Contrary to common perception, changing oil more often than recommended has been shown to increase engine wear. An ongoing University of Michigan study has shown that the greatest wear occurs in the first 3000km of an oil's life in any engine!"

John

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required