When changing engine oil, I've always drained the old oil by the old fashioned method of removing the sump plug.
However, I'm aware that some 'quick oil change' places (and may be others) suck the old oil out using a pipe into the dip stick hole/tube. Plus, the early Smart Cars (the 450's) didn't have a sump plug (although a mod was available), and the standard service method was to suck the oil out. The 451's, at least the later ones, do have a plug.
While crawling under the Ducato this morning to change the oil, I got wondering about the pros and cons of sucking the oil out by the dipstick hole/tube.
One obvious con is the need for the kit, a pro is (presumably) speed and lack of mess. Plus, in some cases, you may be able to avoid having to even put the vehicle on a ramp etc, assuming you can access the filter from above.
I also think sucking may leave some 'sludge' in the sump. I tend to change my oil regularly- before the mileage at least, although only once per year (as specified- I don't cover the corresponding number of miles). However, if you do cover the max number of miles, or don't change the oil regularly, then sludge is likely.
Does anyone have experience of sucking the oil out? I'm not really thinking of changing how I change my oil, I only do a few changes per year and it is hardly a major chore, I'm just curious.