I am looking at a 2001 E class, with the COMAND system. I was wondering
what the general opinion of this system is - is it a decent navigation
system? The car is not local so I cannot look at it first hand. The only
navigation system I have used is one from a 2005 BMW M3 which was DVD based,
and it worked rather nicely.
Is the software expensive to update?
Does the navigation media go in the trunk or in the head unit? Will the
head unit play audio CDs up front, or only in the 6 disc changer in the
WHile we call ours "The Nagging Ninny" due to it's propensity to say
things like "Prepare to drive straight", and it's "tell you everything
three times, prepare to..., ... in xx distance, please ...",I'm glad I
have it. It doesn't always find the 'best' route to a location, but
it does get me where I want, and the maps have been much improved
since I bought mine in 2001.
Not that expensive, I think it's $120(?) but I don't update it every
The NAV CD goes in the head unit, which will also play audio CDs The
6-disk trunk changer is optional, but nice to have. The best part is
the AUX input in the glove box, where I hook up my iPod.
It depends on where you are and how much you travel. Having to shuffle a
dozen CD's is a PITA. Also, many smaller cities are not covered well with
the maps, and in rural areas, about all you get are Interstate and major
Why not see if you can find a similar car locally and play with the
I depends on what you think of as expensive. IIRC, each region (i.e. disc)
is sold separately and is over $100. I seem to remember an option for
buying a complete set for the entire country for around $800. It's been a
while since I;ve looked into it, so I could be wrong.
The CD-ROM reader for the NAV discs is in the head unit and it can also play
audio CD's. That alone can be worth having this unit over the standard
radio where CD's have to go in the changer in the trunk.
I have 2005 C320 and the nav is DVD based and I compared it with the
previuos ones with CD based nav, it is much better but compared to my
infiniti nav the maps are not labeled good, you have to zoom in all
the way to see all streets names even main routes. and the voice guide
is weard, I could not understand what SHE meant sometimes.
On Mon, 28 Feb 2005 16:30:31 -0500, "Jeff"
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.