What is it with plastic headlights? There seems to be an entire range of things happening to the lights on various cars. My 2008 Outback has the slightest bit of surface crazing that is only visible under very close examination. Other cars of similar age and older seem to suffer much worse degradation with some looking like barely-translucent yellow slabs. Is it the material used in the lens? The weather? Bad karma?
There is one thing to say for old-school sealed beam headlights -- glass didn't degrade and if they burned out or broke a quick cheap trip to the parts store and 15 minutes of labor would fix everything as good as new.