Technology gone too far?

Everytime I actuate my Forester headlights I hear the 'pop' of a relay somewhere under the right side dashboard. I question the use of a relay. Is this technology simply because you can?

Now, I remember when headlights were turned on by pulling out a knob two clicks. (I also remember a time when Americans would have been outraged to pay for water, one of the slickest scams every perpetrated on people, but I digress.) How is the newer system an improvement? Only 2 possible ways: one, the modern system prevents dead-battery by turning off your lights, and two, the daytime running-light safety feature.

Everyone suffered from the dead battery syndrome from time to time, but only really stupid people were afflicted often, so it wasn't a huge problem. Also, the warning buzzers that began in the 80s or so modified the system so that you had to be really really stupid to get stung.

As for a safety feature, I wonder if it couldn't be done more simply without a relay. I remember when daytime running lights were a trick mostly only used by motorcycles. One wonders if the safety effect will be lost when all cars have the feature.

At any rate, I think the headlight relay is another unnecessary sophistication that can break down. I guess I have sufficient affluence that it will be someone else's problem, as I will trade in 5 years or less.

Okay, lay on boys, that's my rant, and damned be him who first cries, "Hold! Enough!"

Old fashioned Pete

Reply to
P T
Loading thread data ...

There are actually multiple relays. The one you hear is inside the car, but there are others under the hood. The one inside (by the glovebox) does have to do with the DRL system, it switches the low beam ground circuit between normal mode(regular switched ground) and DRL mode (grounded through the DRL dropping resistor for reduced intensity). When you turn on the headlight switch the relay activates and you hear the click. There are also two relays under the hood for the headlight common power, one for each side, that are activated when you turn the lights on. \ The use of relays in modern cars is not an inherently bad idea, as it allows for the heavy electrical load to be carried by the relay and not the switch in the car, which means that the switches and their associated wiring can be lighter since they don't need to carry all that current. This actually increases the reliability of the switches, although Subaru's switched ground system does actually run the headlight ground current directly through the switch so only the positive side has the benefit of relays taking the load. If you are electrically inclined, it is possible to add ground-side relays(yes, more relays) to eliminate the voltage drop that occurs as a result of this arrangement and make the lights brighter. It is true in general that there is far more complexity in electrical systems now, and while much of it is good, it may be overdone in some cars and certain areas. Current BMWs and MBs are a prime example of too much technology causing both reliability problems and techno-overload for the driver. Subaru is nowhere near as guilty of adding unnecessary gadgets and circuitry as many other manufacturers. Personally I'm not afraid of the electronics and electrical stuff in modern vehicles, but then again I understand it and how to work with it, the average owner generally doesn't. Unfortunately many old-school mechanics can't deal with it either.

P T wrote:

Reply to
mulder

I can remember when that knob actuated a relay.

Many new headlights draw more current than older models. The wiring to support that current, along with the proper switch contacts probably wouldn't fit well in a control stalk.

Relays aren't new technology, and are plenty reliable when spec'ed properly.

Barry

Reply to
Bonehenge

I'm remembering that too, in 60s cars. Knob, relay, headlight.

Reply to
David

I was reading that too, and while I agree on the topic of overteched cars, I had to pause and ask myself, "Relays?" I'm sure that there are some pretty high tech relays by now, but the core concept of the relay is definitely old school.

Also, I haven't priced relays lately - but I'm sure that a relay is cheaper than a proprietary switch, even if the relay itself was proprietary.

-Matt

Reply to
Hallraker

It's a good idea to run the power of headlights through a relay and not through the dash mounted switch.

In fact it's a great idea to retrofit older cars that _don't_ have such a feature, generally improved lighting is the result.

Google is your friend:

Now, if you want to talk about tech going too far you could have chosen sooo many other and better examples:

(Not Subaru specific) Not having a dipstick to check the oil. Having a big plastic cover over the motor to keep the DIYer from doing anything. Having to drop the motor out to get at.... (any number of things). And so one.

TBerk

Reply to
T

daytime running daylights saved me 90 dollars on my insurance. The hell with going back to the 80's

Reply to
Juan Otero

In many ways it is actually a weight reduction issue as well. If you run thin wires to a relay that is closer to the headlights and then thicker gauge wire to the headlights, you can save a few ounces and, more importantly (for the manufacturer), a few cents on each vehicle you produce since thin gauge wire is less expensive than thicker gauge wire. Relays are cheap, I can buy them for under $1.25...so imagine how cheap FHI must be able to buy them.

I imagine that relays will go away over time by use of FET's or some other CPU based function.

Reply to
EQ Shaman

I can see how FETs or the CPU can handle the switching jobs, but can they take the place of relays for pure current flow?

Rick

Reply to
Rick Courtright

In theory, certainly. If FET can be used to switch power in a 2500+ Watt RMS Amplifier, they should be able to handle headlights, door lock, etc....

Reply to
EQ Shaman

This is from

formatting link
"High-power IGBTs combine the easy drive and current-sharing characteristics of MOSFETs with 1-µsec switching times...Devices such as Eupec's FZ600R65KF1 turn on in less than 1 µsec and off in about 6 µsec to control 1.2 kA at 6 kV; lower voltage devices such as the company's FZ3600R12KE3 switch 3.6 kA at 1.2 kV."

mikey

Reply to
mikey

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.