From the LA Times: Sales of smaller fuel efficient cars was up for the last quarter, with peope abandoning 6 cyl enginef for fours.
For my 1995 Tercel 2dr DX, here's the KBB, Private party value:
Condition Value Excellent $2,600 Good $2,235 Fair $1,835
When I sold it in 2005 with 125,000 miles on it, it was valused at $2425, Good condition. I guessed the girl I sold it to doesn't drive much, so this computation is for a Good condition car with 175,000 miles on it.
I'd say a loss of $200 for 2 years for a 12 YO small car is not too bad, all in all...
My Supra did even better:
Condition Value Excellent $4,140
Last time I did it was with 165,000 miles, and the value was $3425. This time is with 200,000 miles, and two years older.