Learned Opinion Needed: Composite or Metal Water Pump replacement

Jan 03, 2006 1 Replies

A thread on Pelican forum indicated that the Water Pump replacement with the Black COMPOSITE material impeller is the preferred choice now



- over the metal impeller version.



Would you agree? Why/why not? Are the earlier problems with composite material becoming brittle a thing of the past?



My car is a 1993 325i E36, M50 engine sedan.



I'm 100% sure my water pump just failed and I need to start that repair project.



I'd appreciate a authoritative answer to this choice. Thanks.



I spoke with a few mechanics, and for various reasons, they all said to stick with the metal....

I thought I had a bad water pump - I had ZERO head pressure -- I mean; the pump would "take" water; but I never achieved any pressure. I replaced it; still none. Could be an M30 issue -- I don't know.

How are you 100% w/o removing it? or have you?

--- AntiSpam/harvest --- Remove X's to send email to me.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required