SEems like ford is STILL having transmission failures... buddy of mine
has a 5spd 3.0L ranger, tranny went at 12,000, took them 42 days to fix
it, and he just got it back yesterday. another buddy just bought an
escape to head out west, brand new, 7000k, tranny went, doesn't know if
he'll make it out west by new years...
at work, one ranger 3.0L auto, two tranny failures, one a complete
rebuild, truck had less than 80k on it both times. now the other one
was an 02, with 220k (talking kilometers here) and it failed, it was
also automatic. Thats not real good out of 5 rangers. (3 are 05's, 2
02's). The other 02 only has 120k kms on it, and it hasn't failed yet
I had a 98 Ford windstar that dropped 2 trannies in 28k miles and now
have a Honda Odyssey on its 4th tranny at 100k miles. There will be no
more mini vans for my family when this one is gone. btw, had a dodge
crapavan before the ford and the trannys and AC were good for about 20k
miles also. I don't think there is a good minivan.
The Astro was actually a decent minivan, it just didn't appeal to the
soccer mom set due to its truck-based nature. However, it proved to be
a good, reliable service vehicle and therefore would probably have
lasted forever in soccer mom duty.
Of course, as repeatedly stated earlier in this thread, they aren't
made anymore, and there's no new equivalent from any manufacturer of
which I'm aware.
| I had a 98 Ford windstar that dropped 2 trannies in 28k miles and now
| have a Honda Odyssey on its 4th tranny at 100k miles. There will be no
| more mini vans for my family when this one is gone. btw, had a dodge
| crapavan before the ford and the trannys and AC were good for about
| miles also. I don't think there is a good minivan.
I have a 2000 Safari with 80K miles that has only had maintenance
performed on it so far. Transmission was flushed at 60K. Just put the
third set of tires on it this month.
----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Unrestricted-Secure Usenet News==----
Your experiences could well say more about your driving style than the
viability of minivan transmissions. In my 45 years of driving, I've only had
one auto trans fail, and it had over 200k miles on it.
Dave, I have owned 18 vehilces in my life and did not have one tranny
problem except on minivans. I have ALL my trannies serviced every 20k
miles and drive very easy. Have you done a search on Honda and windstar
tranny problems? The 00-01 odyssey was so bad that Honda extended the
warranty to 100k on my year model. Now Ford was a different story.....
I had a 95 Windstar with 170K km on it with no sign of transmission trouble
when I traded it on Venture. The Venture had some slipping problems when I
traded it on an 03 Windstar.
I asked the opinion of a local well respected transmission shop on which
current domestic minivan has the best transmission for pulling my 2500 lb
boat. He said they are all "pretty good" and should be ok if they are
serviced regularily. Of course the trans cooler is a must. The ford and
chev allow you to disable the overdrive when towing, the Chrysler doesn't.
Therefore I eliminated the Chrysler.
BTW, I love my Windstar. By far the most comfortable of the big three.
Denis Roy < email@example.com> wrote in message
In other words you don't care if you have a tranny problem, as long as
somebody else pays for the repair? ;)
If I could get a discount of several thousands dollars by not getting ANY
warranty, I would take the discount. I haven't had a problem with any
vehicle, foreign or domestic, in over twenty years.
On Wed, 27 Dec 2006 13:30:58 -0600, Hairy got out the hammer and chisel
and etched in the wall:
Possibly, but those two instances have known issues. The ford FWD 3.0 (?)
tranny was known for failure. Also, I've read of several people with the
Honda 3.5 engine who've had tranny issues. My wife's VUE with a 3.5 so far
is okay, but I'm crossing my fingers. :)
I was selling these for a while and we could never get enough Astro vans for
the trade. Not only did GM stop making them, they closed the plant in
Baltimore to boot. From what I understand the Astro was doing well on the
coasts but not elsewhere. I'm sure they could have kept it going somewhere.
It's kind of amazing, really, that GM is the world's largest company and
there are so many markets that they don't even sell to. They don't even
care. For instance, they had unreliable junky diesel trucks that nobody
would buy. They let that drag on forever. They didn't field a 4-door small
(now considered mid-sized) SUV for a long time. They made a half-hearted
effort with the stretched S-10, but that was just a pile of junk. They just
watched while Jeep and Ford ran away with a huge market. How about this -
no extended cab pickup until 1988. 15 years later to the market than the
2nd slowest. How about a competitor to the Mustang? Nope. Police car?
Nope. How about something you could use for a Taxi? Nope. How about a
low-slung 12,000 lb GVWR truck for rollback service, like an F-450? Nope.
Minivan? Nope. V-8-powered rear drive car? Well, yes, at a price much
higher than a 300C.
To be fair, though, I do see some markets coming back to them, and Ford
doing some of the same kind of ball-dropping that GM used to do. In the
1980's, GM squandered Cadillac's leadership position through a superhuman
effort to embrace every kind of mistake possible. It appears that market is
coming back around, or at least you could say Lincoln isn't leading any
I also think the gas mileage of the 5.3 gas-powered trucks may be a class
leader. I'm pretty sure it is.
I think the HHR might be a hit. It may actually be outselling the other
The Impala is a horrible police car. The transmission doesn't last and
where I live it didn't make it as a taxi either.
I don't know where you live but a Corvette used by police enforcement? Palm
Beach or Malibu?
Here in Vancouver the Impala is currently popular as an airport cab, but
the Toyota Corolla is increasingly becoming very common for in town
taxis and even airport use.
A few months ago 4 of us each with a checked bag and a carry on, were
brought home from the airport in a Corolla. It's large space for a
smaller car surprised me; fortunately the three smaller people took the
rear seat and I got the very spacious front seat.
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.