Is it common for a muffler to collapse in the center under normal use?
I just took my vehicle to Midas. They indicated my muffler is not
covered under warranty because I must of had some sort of accident
that resulted in smashing my muffler. Despite not having any accidents
or visible signs of damage to my cars under body, for some reason,
visible inspection of my muffler shows signs of it starting to wrinkle
together in the center with the two ends collapsing like an accordion.
Although I indicated that my car is only subject to normal driving
conditions and is free of any collisions, they charged $323 for a
muffler that should of been covered by warranty. What's your take, can
a muffler collapse on it's own or does it take some sort of external
for to make it start to wrinkle like an accordion?
It's not possible that I backed up into anything. The muffler sits
higher than the axel and other parts. It isn't directly accessible. No
evidence of scrapping or otherwise apart of the under carriage.
No Nate was asking if you backed into anything with the end of your
tailpipe (say backing up and the open end of your tailpipe that hangs
out from *behind* the car hitting a high curb). That could potentially
compress the muffler (although I've never seen it happen)
First of all I would scream at the $323 they charged for a muffler. They are
ripping you off! All of these shops charge whatever they want to for their
services. You would have been further off going to a dealer than paying
those rates.My daughter took her car in for the advertised $16.95 oil
change, she came out with estimates for $500 worth of thing she "needed" for
her car. $94 for spark plugs which I got for about $12 and installed them in
about 20 minutes. It also said she needed spark plug wires for $130, all
that is there is boots that go in there, that didn't need replaced. I heard
these places are real ripoffs, now I believe it!
You don't say what type of vehicle you have. What kind of car is it?
Does the muffler run lengthwise with the car or is it crosswise?
How old is the muffler / exhaust system?
Are there other drivers that drive this vehicle?
Was the car recently hoisted up to be worked on? You know a repair shop
might of damaged it for you & said nothing. Did a mechanic recently
"test" drive the car?
It is possible for something to contact the muffler and damage it
without damaging the undercarriage.
Backing up on uneven ground can cause damage. Was the car recently
parked over a ditch or in a field ( Such as a fairgrounds ) where grass
area's tend to be rutted? Grass surface rubs on the bottom of the car
are easily unheard by the ear.
Another poster mentioned the muffler contacting a snow drift - that's
something that wouldn't show much evidence of scrape marks. Driving
through deep/heavy plowed up snow could also be a possibility.
$323 was alot for a muffler
91 Bonneville 309,327miles (Orig Muffler & Exhaust),
05 Park Avenue 55,125
These "lifetime" warranties are often not worth the toilet paper they
were printed on. The game is to put on the cheapest parts possible and
when you come back to find creative reasons to extract more cash from
You will be much better off if you find a real mechanic at a real shop
who you trust to do honest work for a reasonable price using quality
parts. That is almost never at a chain store like a Midas shop.
Motorsforum.com is a website by car enthusiasts for car enthusiasts. It is not affiliated with any of the car or spare part manufacturers or car dealers discussed here.
All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.