I changed car from a BMW 5 series (old) to a used Boxster a few years ago. Transferred the insurance over - as that was as good a deal as I could find on the comparison sites. It went up, of course, at renewal, but again seemed OK. Just got the renewal in and up again. So went back to the comparison sites. Same thing - seems I've got a decent deal.
So decided to try a not on the sites company. Direct Line, since my house insurance is with them. Cars used to be until they piled on the premiums.
Over a third less than my current insurer. Have the comparison sites lost their edge?