Yes, consumers reports states that Subaru is the most reliable brand overall for 2004 and 2005. This is not an industry mag but an, arguably, serious consumer organization. I generally look at the reliability record over many years and models to give meaningful indication. A one year blip doesn't cut it. For instance, the Ford Focus, had the people at consumers rating it pretty highly..... at first, but they soon had more data from more owners and it slid off the radar. Subaru has had staying power with consumers since the 80's. I bought my first Subaru, a GL wagon, in 86 based on Consumers Reports. I now have a 2004 Forester. I ended up with the Forester over the Legacy models because of the Japan build for the Forester as opposed to US build for the Legacy models.
My 04.... 38,000 and not one problem. Not that I would expect any. The old
86 is still on the road too, as is my 1990 Legacy (Japan build)