I have a 2005 Touareg V8 with Continental 275/45/R19 108Y tires. I banged up the passenger tire by hitting a curb. Took a chunk out of the tire. I need to replace this one tire. However, a dealer is saying that I have to replace all 4 tires to keep them in balance or something. There are only 10k miles on these tires. They are incredibly expensive.
Does this seem reasonable. There is plenty of tread on the tires and it seems odd to have to replace all the tires just to fix one of them.