I've been to a lot of the local tire stores, and have had a lot of trouble finding much selection in the 185/70x14 that I need. But I did find these two, which appear to be well regarded for the money.
The car has 53k miles on it, and I don't anticipate much change in that driving pattern. It's almost all city driving, with one highway 500-mile-round-trip a year.
The BFGs are about $20 more than the Toyos, but based on what I've read I think I would go with the BFGs.
But I would appreciate any first-hand experience with either of these that you guys might want to relate, or any recommendations you might want to offer. I'll probably pull the trigger Tuesday morning.