landrover + AA = doesn't compute

I think that you should send all of the above to the AA, tell them to p*ss off - and join the RAC. I'd also seriously think about sending it to the likes of Watchdog and Top Gear - I doubt it's common knowledge that their patrol staff are now expected to meet certain sign-up targets.

The RAC generally tend to know a little bit about different Landies - they most certainly know what a 101 is - and will know to send a very big flatbed recovery vehicle (as a few of us here have tested, some more than once!).

I have always had good service from my 25 odd years with the RAC. On the one occasion that Charlotte had to call out the AA they took two hours to arrive, then didn't know where the problem was. Now I'm no expert, but a stuck starter solonoid really shouldn't be too challenging, should it?

Martyn

We've had many episodes of 110s on recovery trucks, so I don't think this is true.

Do it. They've recovered me three times in the space of a month for the same problem. I explained that I had sought professional repair several times (and offered receipts) but that the problem was elusive.

No problem, they said and cheerfully brought me home.

The only issue I've had is that after year 1 the costs go up as they discount in year one. I complained that this was hardly a great loyalty bonus but no dice. They did write to me a bit later and give me some money back, so I'm happy as a sandboy.

They also adhere to some good old traditions. My grandmother still gets a Christmas card (personally signed) every year, as my late grandfather was a Superintendent back in the days when they used to salute. I'd never join another organisation out of some illogical loyalty, but they do have a good service ethic.

Tim Hobbs

'58 Series 2 '77 101FC Ambulance '95 Discovery V8i

-snip-

I've learnt a lot about the operation of the AA under the management of Centrica. I've learnt that the AA have closed their service centres, instead relying on the rebranded Halfords chain. This results in customer vehicles being left overnight outside, often in unsavoury locations, whereas before they would be stored in 24 hour manned premises owned/run by the AA. I've learnt about the above policy of getting as much money from members of the AA or members of the public by using the patrol staff as salesmen. I've learnt that they resent this - they are mechanics, not salesmen. In recent times over 20 AA patrol staff have left the company (South Coast area) due to this policy, whereas in previous years there were only a few staff leaving, due to retirement etc. One Patrolman I spoke to said that in over 15 years employment with the AA he had never known so many staff to leave, due to the current working practices.

I left the AA many years ago when they came out against green-laning and sided with the ramblers calling laning anti-social. God forbid they should take the side of the motorists!

Been with the RAC for 5 years or more and had good service.

Kin eck - I really _would_ send all that to Top Gear or somesuch.

Martyn

Trouble is, you'll get stiffed by whichever outfit you choose. I was a long-standing RAC member until they a) told me that I had used my quota one year and would have to pay for future recoveries (3 callouts, from memory) and b) being left on the M4 hard shoulder, past Membury Services, with a 3 week old baby, for two hours at one o'clock in the morning ( despite being told of the urgency!) I'm now with the AA and have had no problems with them (and they've recovered my 130 with the appropriate wagon on more than one occasion.)

Malcolm

I wouldn't bash the patrols, many of then own Land Rovers, and a number even used them in the days when the AA actually bought British. My experience of the RAC was dire regarding Land Rovers, but it just depends who gets your call I suppose! I quit e RAC in digust at their attitude to off-roading (why do they get on the news these days, they are company now not a club representing users interests!) so I supose its just down to individual experience......

Richard

On or around Tue, 16 Sep 2003 21:48:13 +0100, danny enlightened us thusly:

none of which they told us, of course, when asking us to vote on the matter of selling it to Centrica. Buggrem.

I've a good mind to sign up with someone else, on principle, and make sure I tell 'em - recruitment targets for patrols, especially, is just plain silly.

do the RAC get up to similar tricks?

On or around Tue, 16 Sep 2003 23:08:47 +0000 (UTC), snipped-for-privacy@cix.compulink.co.uk enlightened us thusly:

I've known 'em take ages to respond, and the call centre ignore everything and anything you tell 'em about the fault, which can in some cases lead to an inefficient result. I realise that half the world doesn't know the difference between a camshaft and their aunt sally, but when you *do* know what's wrong with it, and tell 'em, it's a pity they don't pass it on to the patrol.

Maybe they don't like to be 'told' exactly whats wrong? They are the 'mechanics'. You know how edgy people can get if they think you're trying to tell them what they already know....admitted if it's something dragging on the carriageway (not unusual in Land Rover World I suspect!) or obvious that's another story.

Mis-diagnosis is easy on some items.

I was in the past a washing machine service engineer and had a MAJOR argument with a customer when he accused me of trying to rip him off. Short story is that his machine wasn't filling with water- 'Water valves gone!' he said as I walked through the door. It could have been (but very uncommon) I tried to suggest alternatives also but he wasn't having any of it. This was BEFORE I even touched the machine!

Shut the t**t up though as he watched every move I made and proved it to be a KNOWN (to me) common fault with a blocked chamber which sensed the water level- simply the machine thought it was full of water already so wouldn't take any more. AHH VERY SATISFYING !!! But the same fault causes many different symptoms....

Dave

Twas Tue, 16 Sep 2003 20:15:37 +0100 when danny put finger to keyboard producing:

Me also.

I had my 110 recovered by an AA recovery lorry, not a subcontractor, one of their own.

no way to push a 110... crap, I've push started both empty and heavily laden 110's, though I'd have rather towed them.

I use the RAC now.

-- Regards. Mark.(AKA, Mr.Nice.) ___________________________________________________________ "To know the character of a man, give him anonymity" - Mr.Nice.

In message , danny writes

My experience is that the AA and the RAC and Green Flag are about the same. Cutting costs to meet competition whilst restricting service to members (sorry paying customers) and at the same time putting up their prices.

I have been a member of the RAC for over 20 years.

My grumble is with their European Service.

My clutch slave cylinder went in France although I did manage to get home (still in France). Not sure of where the nearest Land Rover agent was I rang the RAC only to be told I wasn't covered. So what is this card I have in my hand membership number xxx xxxx xxxx eventually as I watched the minutes on my French mobile home wither I was told I was covered but had to pay another £80 or so as mine was an old vehicle.

I did pay that under protest.

So to the problem. All I wanted was the telephone number and some help in obtaining the part.

We'll send and engineer to assess. But I had assessed I knew the problem and just wanted help to get the part.

The engineer turned up and didn't even look at the vehicle but proceeded to try to pull it up onto his lorry to take it, I know not where. When I telephone the RAC again on my mobile I was told that was the only service they offered. By that time the engineer, sorry driver of breakdown truck had gone. RAC told me I had sent him away and insisted that I should pay for him to come back.

The story gets very long but I am no longer with the RAC for European Assist. A repair which should have cost me £20 in the UK (Parts only) cost me over £400 and left me with a slipping clutch because the parts had been fitted incorrectly.

The recovery and car hire must have cost the RAC, sorry the customers, a fortune, whereas the telephone number of the Land Rover agent would have cost pence.

I'm now covered with the Caravan Club for European assistance though still with the RAC for the UK.

CHRIS

On or around Wed, 17 Sep 2003 14:26:34 +0100, Mr.Nice. enlightened us thusly:

you'd not push-start mine... I guarantee you that.

Yup, I have their 'Arrival' cover too and have it in writing that my

I do wonder though, given your above comments, whether you have simply 'not' left the RAC, but simply changed the type of cover from the RAC. The Camping and Caravan Club 'deal' is really just a 'brand'. Would the 'quality' of the assistance you're offered differ?

Martyn

Not in a landrover but I've had an 'experiance' with the AA. Took a minibus plus 17 passengers to Alton Towers 3 years ago. Got off M6 at Junc

Dom J

In message , Mother writes

There was a bit of a stink when it was revealed that BGAS engineers had similar targets for selling replacement boilers.

I had a spate of calling out the AA - 3 times in 5 months, each time to a different vehicle. As far as I was concerned I had good service from them. The seond time was when the engine on my 110 V8 seized on the day I bought it in the 2nd lane of a 3 lane roundabout. I called the AA and 10 minutes later a vehicle turned up to tow it off the roundabout - and 10 minutes later another one arrived - seemed that the first one was just passing and towed me out of the way simply because it was the right thing to do! There was no problem sticking it on the back of a truck. Third breakdown was on a Wolf (supplied on loan whilst I had a new engine fitted to the 110) which lost all power (fuel starvation problem) - I had the embarassment of being towed by a Frontera type vehicle the 5 miles to home.

Regards

For many years now I've been, on and off, a member of a company called AutoHome. Having owned a succession of rattly old dogs of cars I've called them out on numerous occasions and always been satisfied with their service.

Cheers Gary