New Defender - mini review.

Picked it up this morning for a days worth of test driving.

Positive points.

The engine is utterly superb & pulls like a train from all revs, the torque is incredible, you don't need first gear at all. I just set off in second & it pulls like a train. It is also impossible to stall in first & second gear, superb anti stall system.

Gearbox is precise & very good indeed, sixth gear on the motorway was ace. I looked & was doing 80mph with my foot just touching the throttle. It is just so different to the old Td5.

Seats are comfy & the dash is very good indeed, the ventilation is very good now, no shitty vents etc. The AC works a treat & the heater is bloody boiling!

Road manner are very good, just the usual jiggle from the 90 version, I would hope the 110 to be nicer riding. Damping is much better & springs feel very solid. It feels very planted on the road.

Off road use was minimal, but I'm doing the LRE for Defeners tomorrow, so will let you know how it goes.

Build qualitry felt a lot better than previous models, no rattles that i could hear. A stereo that works & you can hear at 80mph with no problems.

Economy, we had the AC on all day & it was 50/50 town & motorway, we got 29.8 overall. I reckon on the motorway at 60 all day you could get

32-35mpg easily.

Negatives

Why the f*ck do they insist on the drivers door handle to be there, it hurts my leg all day long.

The engine is not as refined as a Td5, put is much better.

All in all a cracking new Defender, it's on my list now.

The funny thing was the abs & TC didn't work as they had nicked the module for a car with a problem........

'That is one bad hat Harry'

Nige

Land Rover Discovery II (2001) Honda CBR900RR Fireblade (1997) Yamaha MT-03 (2006)

Reply to
Nige
Loading thread data ...

I've not seen the dash in real life but in pictures it looks like some huge monster that's crawled into the cab and sits there giving you the evil eye. Does it looked tacked-on and dominating in the flesh?

Hopefully this one will have traction control, I'm interested to know what that turns out like.

Reply to
Ian Rawlings

On or around Tue, 3 Jul 2007 20:42:59 +0100, "Nige" enlightened us thusly:

That's exactly what you want for a test drive, though, find out what it can do without TC... traditionally, 90s are reckoned to be pretty competent with nothing more than a centre diff.

I'll have to go and talk nicely to J.V.Like, see if I can blag a test drive... sounds like it's worth it.

Reply to
Austin Shackles

Did the Land Rover experience today, what a machine, utterly superb. Never braked to go uphill before!

The TC works very well indeed.

Reply to
Nige

Since you mentioned it. What on earth do people mean when they say 'refined'? I have listened to the term used again and again but whatever the context I just can't understand what it means.

I have come to terms with 'leverage' as in 'leverage your investment' or 'leverage your old assets'. It just means 'use'.

But what does 'refined' mean?

Reply to
Peter Harrison

Compare it to oil . I think Nige is saying that the TD TDi and TD5 are like a sticky crude oil slick where as the new lump is like a pool of refined oil... all the pooey bit's taken away but may still smell of cats pee (in the case of EP90) HTH.

Lee

Reply to
Lee_D

Thanks for the in-depth review ;-P

Reply to
Ian Rawlings

OK, here goes. Took the Defender round various tracks & hills with & without TC on. Over the rollers it is easier to get over without having to wiggle the steering or rock & roll it off. When it came to a steep rocky hill with TC off we hit at a slowish speed, no throttle at all, apart from anti stall, once it started slipping just apply a small amount of brakes & up it went. TC on it was up without any slipping. I tried the brake & anti stall on my own D2 auto later on as the TC is borked. As it's an auto & doesn't have anti stall as such (although it does) it started slipping up a steep muddy hill, hit the brakes & up it went. No diff lock on it either, as it doesn't have one.

It does work a treat, but i don't really think it needs it if it's a cost issue.

The engine is utterly superb, just sounds like a bus.

Seat are much improved too.

Reply to
Nige

Cheers mush.

Slightly puzzled by this, coming as I do from 10-year-old technology. Is there brake trickery going on here, i.e. does it release the brake on non-slipping wheels on these newfangled machines even without TC?

Reply to
Ian Rawlings

My guess is it just stops it spining thus sending drive to the other wheels and regaining motion.

But like I say it's a guess.

We used a simialr technique to help free my Fergie TEF-20 the other week when it got stuck up to the axles... although the Fegrie had individual brakes for each drive wheel. As long as it doesn't stall the concept should work fine.

Didn't Rich have a trialler with Jiggle brakes on not so long ago?

Lee

Reply to
Lee_D

Not trickery, as the TC is off no brakes are getting applied (thats how TC works) at all until you apply them by foot. On a hill the rear loads up & the front goes light, the front wheels spin first, hitting the brakes applies the front brakes before the rears slowing the fronts & dropping power to the rear, or thats the way i understand it! Either way, you get up the hill without TC &I proved it in my D2 that afternoon.

Of course TC on youjust drive at the hill on anti stall & up you go.

Reply to
Nige

I know about that trick, have used it myself, but it's often not that effective and takes a lot of practice to get it right, just trying to find out if there is assistance from brainy brakes on later machines or not.

I often found that just jumping up and down on the brakes does it fairly well, for those of us (such as me) who haven't really had the opportunity or need to really master the idea. The original Humvee uses this trick instead of diff locks but it has torsen diffs that greatly over-exaggerate the torque transfer to the non-slipping wheels, either 6x or 10x (can't remember which) the torque gets transferred to the non-slipping wheel than you get using the technique on normal open diffs.

Reply to
Ian Rawlings

Didn't you just get shot of one? Not learned yet then ;-)

Reply to
Ian Rawlings

It all comes down to NVH (noise, vibration, harshness). A bit like comparing the feel/sound/behaviour of the engine in my diesel Hilux to my new Monaro.

Reply to
EMB

Refined mean what it says?

Reply to
Nige

I thought the TC works by selectively applying the brakes on slipping wheels.

Sounds plausible, I've only ever used the brake trick on level ground when stuck in goop, in that case a variation on cadence braking seemed most effective.

Reply to
Ian Rawlings

I like being warm at night - I'll never learn. ;-)

Reply to
EMB

It does, the same way, but more independant.

It works a treat Ian, i tried it several times yesterday & I know i have no diff lock or TC on the D2.

Reply to
Nige

Bet you cant get it into another thread....

Reply to
Mark Solesbury

Already have :p

Reply to
EMB

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.