I can't really answer your question, but for what it's worth, we just installed Goodyear Regatta 2's on our Outback wagon. So far - about
1,000 miles - I've been very pleased. They're quieter than the BFG Precept tires that they replaced, and although we haven't had bad weather yet, I'm confident they'll be better in the snow, too.
FYI, I bought the tires at Just Tires. I did some comparison shopping in terms of buying from Tirerack.com ($64 each) and bringing to an installer for mounting and balancing vs. simply buying at Just Tires ($79 each). Overall (purchase, mounting and balancing), it cost $30 more to simply buy the tires at Just Tires. The convenience was worth a lot more than $30, plus I now get free rotations and balancing at any Just Tires location.