Does this sound like a new starter needed?

Jun 21, 2007 4 Replies

Rate this thread:

First reply

Jeff

It could be the ignition key, bad cables or the solenoid. I would definitely clean the cables and make sure there are good electrical connections first. Try looking at and

Read the full reply

Dave 19 years ago

Got a 1999 4Runner with 176,000 miles on it. Sometimes, when I turn the ignition key the starter (original equipment) hesitates or doesn't crank the engine at all. A second or third try does the trick though and so far I haven't been stranded but this behavior is happening more frequently. The battery is relatively new, about 2 years into a six year guarantee deal.

My novice thinking leads me to believe the starter may be going.

What do others think? Is this a reasonable service life for a starter? How much does a replacement starter typically cost?

Any thoughts on the subject greatly appreciated.

Dave

Vote

Jeff 19 years ago

It could be the ignition key, bad cables or the solenoid. I would definitely clean the cables and make sure there are good electrical connections first.

Try looking at

formatting link

and

formatting link

Vote

Fishface 19 years ago

Maybe the contacts. I've done this repair myself, twice, in thirteen years. Here's a thread with DIY links:

formatting link

Vote

Ray O 19 years ago

As Fishface mentioned, it sounds more like starter solenoid contacts. Check them out first.

Vote

mack 19 years ago

Given the facts as stated, 8 years and 176K miles, I'd guess a new starter is in order. It MIGHT be other lesser parts like the selenoid or whatever, but I think you'll be better off pulling the starter and testing it.

Vote