Took both my RX-8 and my buddy's S197 out for a track day - here's how they stacked up

Nov 19, 2026 Last reply: 1 hour ago 4 Replies
Jump to replies (4)

Spent Saturday at the local track running my RX-8 and my friend brought his V6 Mustang, so we swapped a few laps between sessions. Figured I'd share since these two come up in arguments all the time. The Mustang felt heavier everywhere, no surprise there, but it was way more forgiving when you got sloppy. You could carry too much speed into a corner, grab a handful of brake, and it just kind of shrugged and kept going. The RX-8 rewarded precision but punished laziness. Miss your braking point and the front washes out fast. When I drove it clean it was genuinely quicker through the twisty stuff, mostly beacuse you can rotate it with the throttle and it just tucks in.



Straight-line the Mustang wins easily, obviously. But the biggest difference was how I felt after. Ten laps in the RX-8 and my arms were cooked. The Mustang you could drive all day. If I only had one car for a casual track day I'd prolly keep the Mustang, honestly. But nothing beats the feeling when the rotary stuff actually comes together.


Ran a base S197 for three seasons of track days before swapping it for an RX-8, so this tracks with my experiance almost exactly. The Mustang never let me get in trouble. I remember spinning it exactly once in two years, a mid-corner lift at Gingerman that just resulted in a graceful slide onto the apron and a shrug. Try that in the RX-8 and you are collecting cones at best.

What surprised me after the swap was the tire bill, not the lap times. The Mustang ate rear tires but the fronts lasted forever. The RX-8 wears all four pretty evenly and needs alignment checks way more often, especally if you get sloppy over curbing. Budget for that if you are choosing between them.

The arm fatigue thing is real too. My first full day in the RX-8 I honestly thought the steering was broken, it felt that heavy compared to what I was used to. By the third session my forearms were done but my lap times kept dropping, which tells you something about where the fun lives.

I still keep a tow strap and a full coolant bottle in the RX-8 trunk, which probably says everything about the ownership experience. woud not trade it back though.

I'll give the RX-8 my vote for actual track use, just for running costs alone. I did a season of HPDE in my 2009 Sport with the 6-speed and the thing is cheap to keep on track. My buddy runs a GT S197 and we compared receipts after every event. He was eating front pads, the stock pads were gone in maybe four or five track days and he upgraded to a better pad compound, which then ate the rotors faster. My little 18 inch wheels take a much cheaper tire and the stock brakes held up fine once I bled them properly and kept fresh fluid in there. The rotary does add its own list though. I check the oil every session, top it off before every run group, and I run a little premix in the fuel. That's just part of owning the car and it's honestly not a big deal once it becomes a habit. Where I'll disagree with the OP is on driver fatigue. Mine doesn't cook my arms, but I did remove the stock seats aren't the issue, it's the low steering effort. Maybe the S197's hydraulic steering is what wore him out, I don't know. Either way, both cars are way more fun than they have any right to be for what they cost used.

The part that never gets mentioned in these comparisons is the throttle work. My '04 V6 needed to be rowed hard, third gear pull out of every slow corner because it had nothing down low. Friend's RX-8 would just walk away from me mid-corner while I was grabbing gears. Ran a 1:41 at our local 1.7 mile course in the Mustang and figured low 1:30s was posible in the rotary with the same driver. Also, the V6 wants premium if you're flogging it, otherwise it pulls timing and feels gutless by session two. Cheap car, not cheap to run hard.

Never driven either of these, the closest I got was a rented muscle car in Vegas that about terrified me, so take my take with a grain of salt. Reading this the thing that stands out is how worn out you got just from turning the wheel. Ten laps and cooked arms sounds brutal, but also kind of like the whole point if the car makes you earn it. Only thing I keep hearing about these rotary cars is that the engine drinks oil between gas fills. Is that actually true or just an old story people repeat?

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required