Hi:
I'm thinking of buying a A4 Jetta TDI. Just looking for some opinions on Manual vs. Auto based on fuel consumption, longevity, maintenance etc..
One of the major maintenance differences that I'm aware of:
- Manual timing belt replace at 96K kms. approx. vs. Auto timing belt at 60K kms. approx.
Looking for some info on the following:
- Fuel consumption (L/100 kms.)
- Longevity
- Maintenance
- Any Specific Issues
- Anything else?
Thanks in advance,
AJ.
42 mpg City / 49 mpg Hwy
(I am too lazy to metric-ize)
I hear it is better to have a manual tranny for longevity
Probably about the same. If one is more than the other I would say an auto is more high-maintenance. It is foolish to not maintian a vehicle
my shifter broke recently in my 99 TDI at 86K
More fun to drive a manual, I like to control the car's shift points depending on my mood/ and driving conditions.
I'm old and I don't like to shift anymore... so it's and auto that gets my vote. I have yet to replace a TDI auto trans.
From sometime in 2001 the automatic TB is 80,000 miles (I have an 2002). When you get a TB there is a new one with a few replacement parts that make TB good for 100,000 miles (just had it installed).
Biggest difference is in the mileage. I get 37 around town and any where from 40-46 on the highway depending on how loaded down and speeds (I drive fast). Manuals will get close to 50mpg on the highway.
No problems with my AT with 80K on it. Like anything nothing is perfect. If you check tdiclub.com you will see lots of opinions.
Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.
Ask the community — no account required