Porsche 911 (996) Tiptronic - good? Paging TDM!

Jul 01, 2008 108 Replies

The fact that dealer sticker prices on nearly new cars that are about to be hit with high levels of VED are falling by the week.

Yes, but that's true for most high-VED rate cars.

Erm, you're confusing the issues here.

Unless it's a cabrio, that's not an issue.

When you know prices are falling, and could quite possibly be hit with a bigger fall due to the VED, then it's a very good plan to wait and see.

Like I say, nothing to lose in doing so but potentially enough to gain to keep it on the road for a year or two.

Depends on if 'having a house' means 'will own it when the mortgage has been paid off' or 'own it outright', really.

Putting £25k into a Porsche when you still owe money on a mortgage is, frankly, bloody stupid - especially whilst rates are rising, deals are hard to find and banks are demanding increasingly large deposits.

Best thing we ever did was clearing the house with a combination of inheritance and making money out of a rising market, rather than putting the money into depreciating toys.

As I have said, that value of 'toy' has attracted the re-mortgagers in recent years, so I'd really be thinking carefully about buying just as a full-on recession hits. Better to sit on the cash until people start to crash and burn.

Well good luck with it and can I dribble over the bonnet? Tim Kemp knows how much I love 911s. Tim "ten seconds slower in the 911 in the wet" Kemp hehehe. Oh okay, Tim "a minute quicker in the 350Z in the dry" Kemp then. :)

But really, trying to justify a 911 on cost grounds, whatever next..?

"Alfa Driver in Financial Wisdom Shocker"

I've always had that, why do you think I drive Alfas?

Cheap as chips, 'cos they depreciate quicker than anything this side of a Kia Magentis.....

And shall we even mention the Jags and the FPAs???

No. People don't buy Porsche 911s because they're sensible compared with normal machines.

They buy them because they can and they want to.

Nope. It's about structured debt. Rates may be going up, may be going down, but the chances are that capital locked up into a house is cheaper to fund than by other means. It's also not enjoyable and illiquid. Can't easily sell it. Asset rich, cash poor.

Yadadada you have such acumen and so much more money than I do.

Full on recession? Maybe.

No. Better to enjoy something now if one is able to afford it, than not to, if one can't. Like I say, all this bollucks about waiting here, waiting there, dick-dancing about; it's a 911. You're trying to justify it from that Lupo TDI perspective. Not the same.

*cough* Clio.

Did you see the location for Saturday?

hmmm - a quick nonscientific look at the asking price on autotrader of cars up to 3 yr 40k miles where the model is current reveals this...

Car New 3yr40k £loss %loss Kia Magentis 14645 3695 10950 74.76955 Alfa 147 13955 4800 9155 65.60373 Mercedes A150 14065 6699 7366 52.37113 Phantom 250000 175000 75000 30 Chevy Matiz 6265 2800 3465 55.30726 Smart 6530 4999 1531 23.44564 Saab 9-3 18925 5850 13075 69.08851

75% loss in 3 years!!! Who the hell buys the things!

The 9-3 depreciation is quite comical, too.

Not as comical as it is on the Cadilac version, though.

Not over, just on hold for a while

The BLS? Bit Like a Saab? Not been around 3 yrs but appears to have dropped about 62% in 2 yrs anyhow!

We're gonna near ear plugs. Did you tell Adam? :0

Well, I appear to know more about it than you......

Only because you have nothing better to do than argue every single anal point. So if quantity of posts counts, you have a point.

In terms of quality, my cat knows more about what has happened, is happening, and is probably to happen to the economy than you have demonstrated thus far.

Hmm. Do you want me to have a word with my Porsche bloke? He's in Sheffield, so not hugely out of the way.

Well, he's not buying yet, an is definately a 'main dealer' type shopper. But I may well ask for some advising in a few months if we're both still around hehe :-)

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required