Saab 9-5 main beam relay fails. Dealer charges 90 UKP to 'locate fault'.

After a brief stop last monday evening both main beams on my Saab 9-5 (new mid-1999) failed to work even though they'd worked fine previously. Each beam has own fuse, and very unlikely both would fail together, so sounded like the main beam relay. By phone the service guy at Saab main dealer agreed this seemed likely, so I booked it in for collection, repair, and for two new tyres at the same time.

When car delivered back the invoice shows over 400 UK pounds. Worse, one item is 90 UKP for 'tracing fault in electrical system and localising to main beam relay'. (Relay itself another 39 UKP). The garage service department justified it by saying the 'engineer' spent '2.49' hours on the whole job (including tyre fitting and balancing) at 79 pounds per hour. Said they had to go through a 'structured fault-finding scheme' to locate the relay problem. To me it's an exorbitant charge for proving the obvious.

Two years ago I got suspicious when I collected a replacement remote control key unit I'd ordered. The guy at the desk went in the back and I overheard a muttered exchange: 'What should I charge for it?'. Answer: 'Hmm, what about 150 quid?'

I'd intended to buy a new 9-5 from this same dealer when the new version comes out (making it my fourth new Saab from them over the years) but the way I feel right now, they're the last ones I want to buy from. Snag is they're the nearest dealer and I'm not sure if others would collect and deliver for servicing. Maybe it's time to forget Saab...

I'd appreciate second opinions on this. I expect to pay a reasonable premium for good service if they're honest with it, but this 'fault-finding' charge makes me feel I've been taken for a mug once too often.

Reply to
David Tong
Loading thread data ...

'fault-finding'

I don't like the idea of using a main dealer if one is running a 6 year old car unless you have your own business ( unlikely with a 6 year old car) or have an expense account. Write the bill off to experience and either do the work yourself or find a small outfit that specialises in Saabs. I am sorry you have been caught but someone has to pay for the nice showroom and the smartly dressed staff. I hope you used the coffee machine.

Reply to
John Hudson

in article snipped-for-privacy@brightview.co.uk, John Hudson at snipped-for-privacy@post.com wrote on 29/10/2005 20:07:

I'd echo that sentiment - sounds like you need a specialist, rather than using the main st^H^Hdealer. I'm sure if you posted where in the UK? you are, recommendations will be forthcoming.

Paul

1989 900 Turbo S
formatting link
Reply to
Paul Halliday

If you're daft enought to ask a Saab dealer to fit you new tyres they probably took you for a mug who wants to be overcharged.

How much were the tyres btw ?

Graham

Reply to
Pooh Bear

snip

Thanks to those who responded to my rant. Maybe I've been a mug, but minimising hassle and extra cost go together so I don't mind paying within reason. But I don't think this is reasonable. I'd call it 'killing the golden goose'. Anyway it's lost them a new car sale as a result.

Anyone know a good Saab specialist in the Leeds (UK) area?

David.

Reply to
David Tong

MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.