The correct type of antifreeze can be purchased for any vehicle.
The correct type of antifreeze can be purchased for any vehicle.
i second that...
Systems are engineered using available standard materials. I have seen no indications that Honda has used systems that has forced or required a technological breakthrough in auto fluids.
The probability that Honda branded antifreeze is made on the same equipment with the same ingredients and with the same process as Prestone (or some other high volume manufacturer) is very high. There are many non-silcate brands available.
i don't use honda branded brake fluid or coolant. but i do use honda branded atf and power steering because of past problems. when i was young and dumb, you couldn't tell me that it was worth paying for honda atf - afterall the book said it was just dexron II spec. however, when my car started to shift badly after i changed out the fluid, you'd think i'd learn, right? no. long story short - several cars [not just mine], and some time later, the penny finally drops. honda atf /is/ different. and a honda starts to shift better again immediately you revert back to their stuff.
same for power steering fluid and watching people get leaks a couple of months after using generic. multiple times over the years [though fortunately, not on my cars]. i understand honda p/s fluid has silicone in it and hardware different seal materials. don't ask me why.
right - it paper-trails the production - iso9001 [etc] has nothing to do with whether the spec was written correctly or is appropriate. it's incredibly common for someone to spec the wrong material for a job - but it's still perfectly iso compliant!
indeed. but i return to the original point - i can tell you from experience that two "generic" products used on hondas are not generic at all - atf and p/s fluid. just because others practice what you say, doesn't mean they all do.
it's not so long ago that you couldn't get non-silicate antifreeze at the auto parts store - just like it took some time after honda engine oil spec changed to 5w-20 before you could buy generics of that weight.
bottom line - in a lot of cases, you can buy a perfectly decent generic qualified for its job. but the manufacturer brand is a /guarantee/ it will work - generic is not.
we can agree on that - in principle.
search the honda newsgroups - there's a tom of people disagree with you on the atf/psf thing.
what atf do you use? and how often do you change it?
About eight months ago, I went looking for new windshield wiper refills for my 1978 Dodge van.There are four auto parts stores within about three miles of me.Autozone, NAPA, Advance, and O'Reilly's.(there are many more auto parts stores around here, but I will not drive all over town) Only O'Reilly's had the refills I needed. cuhulin
Anything you can buy in the stores that meets Honda specs is just as good.The only Honda vehicle I have ever owed before was a second hand Honda Moped, back in the 1970s. cuhulin
In addition, corrosion is a slow process. Who is going to notice the difference? It affects the water pump or radiator more than the engine.
green stuff isnt good with aluminum.
ive never had a prob with using the red dexcool (silicate free, aluminum safe) on any of my japanese vehicles. and unless the brake system uses silicone fluid, regular DOT 3/4 works great, changed every 2-3yrs as required.
i do agree totally with you on the tranny fluid, though. thats a common issue, and not just on hondas. Mopar has their own spec, as well.
IIRC, VAG (volkwagen/audi) spec a different type of coolant.
FWIW, toyotas ATF is "lifetime" and the coolant is good for 120k.
Whose to say another manufacturer doesn't make a product that is superior performance?
That is a pretty accurate summary.
Has anyone tried above recommendations?
how many coolant pump failures have you had? and why did you bother to use non-silicate if this subject is such a non-issue?
easy - longevity. japanese manufacturers differentiate themselves with longevity. europeans don't design for mileage much over 100k. in fact, they frequently design /against/ it. why waste money on a higher spec coolant if the car's only got so long to live?
MotorsForum website is not affiliated with any of the manufacturers or service providers discussed here. All logos and trade names are the property of their respective owners.