OT: Source for decent knives?

Aug 22, 2006 32 Replies

First reply

Dave R

I can thoroughly recommend the Gerber range, not the cheapest things in the world but by far the best in my opioion, i've worked in the marine industry for many years, and quite a bit of it on the water. They've never let me down and have always been replaced because of being…

Read the full reply

Wotcher all, I'm in the market for some decent knives, a short sheath knife (say 4 inches) and a 12-inch parang of similar type to the following;



formatting link
The problem I'm having is finding one that I can be sure is of any use. The parang on the above link has a rubber handle, unknown metal blade and you're probably paying £20 extra just because it says "special forces" on it.



Most sites I've found stock decorative knives, made of stainless steel, or have handles that are rivetted on the handle surface (causes blisters) or are made of rubber/rope etc. There's some quite ludicrous sites out there with masses of daft knives that look nice but seem to be inferior quality, quite why there's such a market in trinket knives I don't know.



For both the parang and the short sheath knife I want a wooden handle that has the blade's tang going all the way through and rivetted on the end. The metal should be hardened at least, not stainless steel. I don't want compasses and fishing kits built into the handle, they just weaken it. The short knife needs a mostly straight cutting edge without decorative curves that make it hard to sharpen.



For the "we'll all be murdered in our beds" brigade, these are to go in the pinz/lane clearance toolkit in the back of the truck, not for strapping to my side and striding around the high street or bolting to the dash in full view.


I can thoroughly recommend the Gerber range, not the cheapest things in the world but by far the best in my opioion, i've worked in the marine industry for many years, and quite a bit of it on the water. They've never let me down and have always been replaced because of being lost as opposed to corrosion or breakage.

Dave

yep - I've never bought any knife online/mail-order, nor am I likely to. Choosing a knife is a similar process to choosing a guitar. Amongst other things, the individual unit has to 'feel right'.

schoolyard bling?

The handles made of leather are very comfortable and wear well.

Good luck - seems every knife maker has become infatuated with shiny blades.

Meant to add: have you tried your local huntin' fishin' shootin' shop?

Apparently you local Police Station will have quite a few they don't know what to do with ;-)

Richard

Not yet, given that nothing's local to me, I have to find one first! Anyone got any good ones in the Dorset/Somerset/Wiltshire area?

I'd have thought the only ones handed in would be rusty old bayonets or ornamental gurkha knives, decent ones would be actually in use!

Mind you Lee could set up a lucrative sideline in flogging trinket knives on the side ;-)

aye - and any reports of confiscated knives found to be already coated in finger printing dust are mere media fabrication.

The Glock Field Knife 78 is a good all-round knife, although it probably is a bit long (some 11 inches overall)

formatting link
blade is high-grade steel (not stainless, if you don't take proper care for it, it will rust), the handle is made from the polymer stuff Glock uses for their gun frames. Very strong!I use one and it does the job. Paid some 50 Euros for it incl. VAT and P/P, so it's relatively cheap.

On or around Tue, 22 Aug 2006 11:04:17 +0100, "William Tasso" enlightened us thusly:

mind, modern stainless steel is a bloody sight better than it used to be.

still prefer a plain steel blade though. well, not too plain - hardened, obv.

It used to be said that land rover spring leaves were a nice bit of steel for making knife blades from. never actually finished the one I started making, so I can't vouch for that.

Try

formatting link
, a whole range of cutting tools in hisonline store including the famous Woodlore Knife. If anyone knows theirknives, I guess he does. Pricey though...

Famous?

No kidding - Price: £235.00 (inc VAT) & out of stock too! but you can sign up to the waiting list.

Marketing driven demand at its finest ;)

Famous 'cos he's always recommending it in his programs (well he would wouldn't he!) Hand forged by one guy is the last I read, hence the waiting list and the price. There are some other nice blades on the site though...

Yeah, side-facing rivets in a wooden handle don't float my boat! The rest of the knives aren't what I'm after either, rubber handles etc.

I'd already decided on a Gransfors axe in another store, I quite like their double-headed competition throwing axe but I don't think I'll go for it ;-)

You can get better from army surplus stores, but still not what I'm after though.

This is looking more like it, will try to find how to get them in the UK.

formatting link

In which case I'd suggest a secondhand elwell hedge laying billhook, a large folding pull saw (gomboy) and one of the smaller opinels.

Here's one I prepared earlier:

formatting link

AJH

I've got the saws, including a bowsaw and a surprisingly useful "pocket chainsaw" which works much better than I'd hoped.

What advantages does the billhook have over a more conventional machete?

Shorter, better control of the cut because of the hook, less likely to glance off and the ability to move things with it.

AJH

On or around Tue, 22 Aug 2006 14:01:11 +0100, Ian Rawlings enlightened us thusly:

depends on how they're done, though. If done properly the whole thing is smooth, and it's still probably the best way of actually getting the handle to stay on.

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required