Any preference for tyres?

Apr 29, 2010 25 Replies
52-plate Nissan Maxima QX 3.0 V6 SE Plus Auto (sort of a "luxury" saloon if you're wondering)

Tyres currently on there are Michelin Pilot Premacy 215/55 R16 93V. They were already on the car when I bought it two years and 26,000 miles ago, and I've had no reason to complain about them. All the tyres seem to have worn reasonably equally so I think I'm going to have to replace all four at one go.



Seems that to replace them with Primacys again is about £130 a corner, not an inconsiderable sum. So, before I go ahead, anyone got any thoughts or recommendations?



TIA


If you can afford it, stick with what works. I was persuaded to change brands by a tyre dealer once, and ended up regretting it.

Always worth ringing round for a better price however. Independents will often beat the first price you get.

Chris

Cheers Chris. The old "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" did come to mind but just thought I'd ask a wider collective first :o)

Costco is a popular place for buying Michelin tyres. The savings could pay for a year's membership.

Tim

True, but as my nearest Costco is about 40 miles away I would rarely go there. I can't find out how much the tyres would be there in order to find out if it's a viable option - but thanks anyway Tim :o)

"John" gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

A quick look at BlackCircles suggests that's a decent price.

They have Mich Primacy HPs at £133 each, fitted, or Conti PremiumContact

2 at £117. If you're really after saving money, there's not a lot at savings that look hugely worthwhile, but I'd probably lean towards Toyo CF1 at £98.

I'd probably go for the Michs.

Last time I got 205/55 16 and they were £80 or so each at Costco. We do not have one close, but find there is a significant saving....

On Thu, 29 Apr 2010 15:52:43 +0000, Adrian sang, in the style of Bill Bailey:

Kev is going to be along in a few minutes to tell you that you can buy some cheap s**te for 1/3 the price and Adrian doesn't know his arse from his elbow..

Mike P

In message , Mike P writes

I thought that was Telfon Fred's job?

P.S. My vote is for Conti Premium Contact 2.

Mike P gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

There's Federals for £70, a fiver less than Falkens. If you were in a particularly pikey frame of wallet, which would you buy?

Yes, me too.

Paul Giverin gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

They seem to have merged. Is it TeflonKev now? KevlonFred? FredlonKev?

I've got 'em on the front of the Saab at the mo, replacing a set of Pilot Primacies, bizarrely 'nuff.

They're not bad at all. Definitely better than the Mich Energies. I think, on balance, though, I'd go for the Michs if I had the choice, which I don't, because Energies are all Bib sells in 195/60 16 V now.

Without doing a back-and-forth, it's difficult to say (particularly because the Contis went on almost straight after the winter tyres came off), but I'd say the Michs had a bit better turn-in and were a snidge quieter.

I had those Contis on the Touran from new. They lasted 23,000 miles on the front. Switched to Bridgestone ER300 which have now covered 27,000 and still have 3mm on them. Can't tell any difference in handling and they were a few quid cheaper than the Mich or the Conti.

D.

You could try etyres.co.uk - it seems to be some sort of franchise operation. The two gentlemen who replaced the tyres on my car were friendly and polite and seemed to take care over the operation, even putting copper grease on to make it easier to remove the wheels in future. Supplying them with iced water on a blazing hot day might have helped :-) Also, a tenner a corner cheaper than anywhere else I looked.

Have used E Tyres in the past and found them very good (Birmingham area where wife works) although recently they seem to have become dearer than BlackCircles and much dearer than my local independent.

In message , Andrew Morton writes

They sent one gentleman in my case, who fought through snow and ice to get here on the promised day.

Four P6000s for £284.80, not a brand recommendation, (time will tell), but I'm not unhappy with them.

I was pleased with the service.

Gordon H gurgled happily, sounding much like they were saying:

They really do seem to be a Marmite tyre - I've had 'em on a couple of cars and been hugely unimpressed. IIRC, they were on MikeP's MX5 when he stuffed it in the wet...

I was surprised recently to get the best prices from National Tyres online (for some Uniroyals). They were a tenner each cheaper than Blackcircles and twenty quid cheaper than the National Tyres depot that actually supplied and fitted them.

On Fri, 30 Apr 2010 11:18:55 +0000, Adrian sang, in the style of Bill Bailey:

Oh yes, my favourite tyre. They actually gripped well in the dry, but were awful in the wet. They were awful on the Puma in the wet too.Avons on the next MX-5 were lovely tyres though.

The Activa has Michelins on. The only fault is they're a bit noisy. Despite trying on some roundabouts and country roads , I've not come close to having it slide, wet or dry. I'm beginning to get the impression that if you go fast enough to lose an Activa, it's going to result in a very nasty accident..

Mike P

On Fri, 30 Apr 2010 13:42:48 +0100, The Bishop sang, in the style of Bill Bailey:

Go away, cockwit.

Mike P

Join the Discussion

Have something to add? Share your thoughts — no account required.

Didn't find your answer?

Ask the community — no account required